Container cryptic clues
A container puts one bit of wordplay inside another. The outer word holds the inner letters to build the answer.
8 worked container examples from this practice bank.
What it is
Container clues (additions or insertions) nest strings. Energy in a hat for warmth places E inside HAT to make HEAT. Friend outside university wraps PAL around U for PAUL.
Indicators tell you which string is outside and which goes in: in, holding, about, around, wearing, outside of, clutching.
Both pieces must be fairly clued. Guessing a synonym and forcing letters into it without an inner clue is not a container parse.
Containers are nesting instructions. One string is the shell; another is the passenger. Indicators such as holding, in, about, around, wearing, and outside of tell you which is which. Polarity mistakes—putting the shell inside the passenger—are the most common failure mode.
Single-letter passengers appear constantly: energy E, nothing O, piano P, learner L, hydrogen H. Learn those codes once and many containers unlock without a dictionary hunt for the inner piece.
How to spot it
Find an enclosure word, then name the outer and inner supplies separately.
Try inserting the shorter piece at each position in the outer word until the definition matches.
Abbreviations are common inners: energy E, nothing O, piano P, learner L, hydrogen H.
Underline the enclosure word, then label outer and inner supplies before you insert anything. If you cannot label both, you do not yet have a container parse.
Test every insertion slot on paper. The correct slot yields a dictionary word that matches both definition and enumeration. Wrong slots usually yield junk letters.
Common indicators
- in
- holding
- about
- around
- wearing
- outside of
- clutching
- enters
Solving tips
Draw a quick diagram: outer word as a shell, inner letters as a passenger. Holding, in, and about usually put the passenger inside. Outside of wraps the first string around the second.
Single-letter inners are common. Energy E, nothing O, piano P, hydrogen H, nitrogen N, learner L. Learn those codes once and many containers unlock on sight.
Try every insertion point. SEED holding P becomes SPEED only when P sits after S. Systematic slots beat guessing.
Containers can nest in hard newspaper cryptics. This bank keeps one nest so you can see the shell clearly before you add layers.
About as a container flag means around, not an anagram, when it wraps a single letter into a longer word. Context decides.
Write the outer word with a blank slot, then drop the inner letters in. Paper beats memory for longer shells.
Containers are spatial. Sketch the outer word as brackets and the inner letters as a passenger. Holding and in seat the passenger inside. Outside of wraps the first named string around the second. Getting that polarity wrong is the most common miss.
Single-letter passengers dominate teaching sets: E for energy, O for nothing, P for piano, H for hydrogen, N for nitrogen, L for learner, U for university. Memorising ten codes removes half the work.
Insertion position matters. SHARE holding P is not SPARE; the letters do not form that way. Walk the passenger through every slot: before the first letter, between each pair, and after the last, then read each candidate against the definition.
About can mean container or anagram depending on neighbours. If about sits between a letter and a word, try containment first. If about sits beside a jumble of letters that match the enumeration, try anagram.
Containers in hard cryptics nest twice. Master one nest here, then expect newspapers to put a container inside a charade or after a deletion.
Use the hint ladder: definition first, then mechanism. When the second hint says container, you already know to draw the shell.
Containers punish vague polarity. Before you insert anything, underline the outer clue and circle the inner clue. Say the sentence outer holds inner or outer outside inner aloud. If you cannot say it, you cannot place letters. Then run the passenger through each slot on paper. The correct slot is the one that yields a dictionary word matching the definition and the enumeration together. That two-gate check is identical to anagrams even though the letters never shuffle.
Worked examples
These 8 container clues come from this site's practice bank. Read the definition edge, then the construction, then why both sides agree.
Energy in a hat for warmth (4)
HEAT
Definition: warmth (end). Indicator: in. Fodder: energy; hat.
Warmth is HEAT. Energy is E, placed in HAT to make H(E)AT.
- Warmth is the definition.
- In means one letter sits inside another word.
- Put E (energy) inside HAT.
Girl in bed is forbidden (6)
BANNED
Definition: forbidden (end). Indicator: in. Fodder: girl; bed.
Forbidden is BANNED. Girl can be ANN, placed in BED: B(ANN)ED.
- Forbidden is the definition.
- In means a name sits inside BED.
- A common crossword girl is ANN.
Apostle's friend outside of university (4)
PAUL
Definition: Apostle (start). Indicator: outside of. Fodder: friend; university.
Apostle is PAUL. Friend is PAL around university U. Teaching example from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA).
- Apostle is the definition.
- Friend is PAL.
- Put U (university) inside PAL.
Utter nothing when there's wickedness about (5)
VOICE
Definition: Utter (start). Indicator: about. Fodder: nothing; wickedness.
Utter is VOICE. Nothing is O inside wickedness VICE. Teaching example from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA).
- Utter is the definition.
- Wickedness is VICE.
- Put O (nothing) inside VICE.
What holding energy grain (5)
WHEAT
Definition: grain (end). Indicator: holding. Fodder: what; energy.
Grain is WHEAT. Energy is E, held inside WHAT: WH(E)AT.
- Grain is the definition.
- Holding means insertion.
- Put E (energy) inside WHAT.
Seed holding piano for pace (5)
SPEED
Definition: pace (end). Indicator: holding. Fodder: seed; piano.
Pace is SPEED. Piano is P, held inside SEED: S(P)EED.
- Pace is the definition.
- Holding means insertion.
- Put P (piano) inside SEED.
Clan holding European is spotless (5)
CLEAN
Definition: spotless (end). Indicator: holding. Fodder: clan; european.
Spotless is CLEAN. European is E, held inside CLAN: C(L E)AN → CLEAN.
- Spotless is the definition.
- Holding means insertion.
- Put E (European) inside CLAN.
Torn holding hydrogen spike (5)
THORN
Definition: spike (end). Indicator: holding. Fodder: torn; hydrogen.
Spike is THORN. Hydrogen is H, held inside TORN: T(H)ORN.
- Spike is the definition.
- Holding means insertion.
- Put H (hydrogen) inside TORN.
Common mistakes
Swapping inner and outer
Outside of means the first string wraps the second. Read the indicator carefully.
Ignoring abbreviations
Many containers hide a single-letter inner. Learn the standard cryptic letter codes.
Swapping shell and passenger
Outside of A B usually wraps A around B. Holding puts the second string inside the first. Read the indicator polarity before you place letters.
Practice this device
Open unlimited for another clue from the same bank, browse the full puzzles list, or return to all wordplay guides. For the solve order that sits above every device, read how to play.